Tag: mortgage

Alain Sherter Calls It Like It Is!

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Government Failure, Philosophy of Business, White Collar Crime

If you read my blog much, you know that Alain Sherter is one of my favorite writers. Well, he’s hitting one out of the ballpark this time. This is from his article on BNET. It’s called “Foreclosures: Did Wall Street Banks Conspire to Rob Homeowners?” Read! –

Are the financial firms alleged to have fraudulently repossessed people people’s homes more like the gang that couldn’t shoot straight or the mob? That question underlies the spreading foreclosure scandal, and how it is answered could affect any ensuing legal or legislative remedies to resolve the crisis.

Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray is unequivocal in his assessment. In suing GMAC Mortgage and corporate parent Ally Financial in order to to block it from proceeding with any foreclosures in the state, he characterized the company as preying on vulnerable homeowners “through fraudulent and unfair and deceptive practices.”

Now take a look at the previous article – “Foreclosures: Help for Homeowners Means Hurt for Banks.”

The foreclosure crisis is morphing into a full-blown political crisis — and it’s about time. In Washington, lawmakers are urging the Obama administration to investigate whether financial institutions have broken the law in dealing with borrowers at risk of losing their homes. At the local level, legal officials are pressing lenders to cease foreclosures. …

Several things are happening here. First, the foreclosure epidemic, until recently mostly a subplot in the national economic drama, is now front-page news. Revelations that some of the nation’s biggest financial firms, including JPMorgan Chase (JPM), Bank of America (BAC) and Ally Financial, have “robo-signed” people’s homes away have seen to that. With midterms elections only weeks away, Congress has no choice but to sit up and take notice, if only to cover their backs.

Second, more and more homeowners face eviction. One in seven people with a mortgage is past due or in foreclosure, according to the Center for Responsible Lending, a consumer advocacy group. That’s up from one in eight in 2009 and one in 11 the previous year.

You should follow the links and read the whole articles. Better yet, check every few days to keep up with crisis, you can’t do any better that Sherter’s reporting.

James Pilant

Andrew Weighs In On My Post, “Anectdotal Evidence Or Life In The Skycastle!”

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, ethics, Government Failure, White Collar Crime

My buddy Andrew adds his thought to my recent post, “Anectdotal Evidence Or Life In The Skycastle!”

While I agree that a more up to date central title system will help keep mistakes from happening, it is not the problem. The problem is with the banks and how they do business. Thats all there really is to it.

I also agree that we should help out as many people as we can with getting refinanced and keeping their homes. This should especially be done for the people who did fall victim to deceptive lending practices.

However, we must keep in mind that not EVERYBODY who defaults on their mortgage is a poor victim in this case. At the end of the day, these people signed the papers to a mortgage that they couldnt afford. Just because external influences say that its the right thing to do doesnt mean that it ACTUALLY is the right thing to do. When we excuse sheep-like behavior from citizens, then we end up with a population full of sheep. Would you want your son, or any family member for that matter, to make a major life choice based on what external sources say is best, or do you want him to figure out, on his own, what is best for him and go for it?

Dont get me wrong, I do sympathize with the people who honestly fell for deceptive lending practices and fraud. Those people had no way of knowing that they were about to be taken for a ride.

The problem is, like you said, the numbers arent out yet. There is no telling how many people were actually affected by the banks inability to do a simple task such as record keeping. It could be less than 1% or it could be 50%. Who knows at this point.

I believe the banks should have to own up to their mistakes. We can do this by mandating a moratorium on foreclosures until this mess can be sorted out. After everything is sorted out, if you deserve to have your house foreclosed on, then you lose your house. If not, then you get to keep it. Like I said before, this is not mutually exclusive from showing mercy towards those who did fall for these lending practices. Im all for helping them refinance into a more fair situation.

“Foreclosure Fiasco”

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, ethics, Government Failure, White Collar Crime

I borrowed my title from an article series on CBS Moneywatch. I can’t improve on it. It covers eloquently and briefly the situation.

Here’s the lead paragraphs from the article –

After three years of terrible news about the housing market, you’d think it couldn’t get much worse. But over the past week, a whole new can of awful has opened up. It turns out that the banks who lent money with reckless abandon during the real estate bubble were just as incompetent on the way down as they had been on the way up. Big lenders and mortgage servicers have been forced to acknowledge that, as they rushed to foreclose on hundreds of thousands of properties, they didn’t always check to make sure that they actually held the mortgages.

In one case, a Florida man who had paid cash for house was foreclosed upon for defaulting on a loan he never took out. In other cases, mortgage documents have been forged. So-called “robo-signers” have been churning out affidavits without checking to see if they are true. In response, foreclosures are all but frozen in 23 states, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has called for a federal investigation, and attorneys general around the country are seeking to halt foreclosures. One major title insurer has announced it won’t insure homes foreclosed upon by J.P. Morgan Chase. That may sound like a technicality, but if the trend spreads, it could send the housing market into a tailspin.

CBS provides a slide show to give you a quick overview of the crisis. I recommend it.

Do not read the comments on the CBS web site! Trust me. Life is too short for that kind of reading.

The CBS report is a seven parter. If you are interested in how this came about and what is likely to happen, it is the best thing at the moment. I’m sure as time goes by, we’re going to get some better stuff because we’ll have more information, but CBS was first and it’s a good job.

James Pilant

White House Has Supernatural Powers!

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, Government Failure, Philosophy of Business, White Collar Crime

“White House doubts need to stop all home foreclosures” reads the headline. David Axelrod spinning the story like a top explains… well, let’s just let him tell us – from Yahoo News –

A top White House adviser questioned the need Sunday for a blanket stoppage of all home foreclosures, even as pressure grows on the Obama administration to do something about mounting evidence that banks have used inaccurate documents to evict homeowners.

“It is a serious problem,” said David Axelrod, who contended that the flawed paperwork is hurting the nation’s housing market as well as lending institutions. But he added, “I’m not sure about a national moratorium because there are in fact valid foreclosures that probably should go forward” because their documents are accurate.

Axelrod said the administration is pressing lenders to accelerate their reviews of foreclosures to determine which ones have flawed documentation.

“It’s a serious problem.” he says. I get that. So, since the story broke in the middle of last week you are dismissing a moratorium based on virtually no real information? Unless you, kind reader, think a giant national crisis, has run its course and everything is out on the table in the seven days since the story broke. If you don’t, you are with me in the disbelief column. Apparently the White House can see into the future and knows that no information will come out meriting action. I don’t know whether Axelrod has the “sight.” Perhaps, the White House has the super deluxe, limited edition, one of kind, ultimate ouija board. I hear it’s got a presidential seal on it.

But don’t worry, the White House has a plan. Let me run that line past you again – Axelrod said the administration is pressing lenders to accelerate their reviews of foreclosures to determine which ones have flawed documentation That’s right. They are going to go to the guys who lied to the court system roughly one million plus times and ask them to check their numbers. The people who have profited billions of dollars by cutting out those inconvenient legal requirements are gonna’ fix everything.

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. – Maybe someone should send that in to our President?

“Hey, Mr. President, a massive wrong has been done to the American people. Send out the Attorney General! Mobilize the federal government, your regulators, your advisers, every friend you can muster! Let justice fall from Heaven like rain!”

“Oh? You can’t do that, Mr. President? Wouldn’t be prudent? Might upset the financial markets? That justice thing overrated anyway? Oh, I’m sorry I didn’t understand the burdens of your office. I’m sorry to bother you. Thanks for the engraved napkin.”

Yeah, everything going just fine.

James Pilant

Jon Stewart’s Take On The Mortgage Foreclosure Crisis – WARNING, Strong Language

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, Economic measurement, ethics, Philosophy of Business, White Collar Crime1 Comment

Jon Stewart sums up the crisis brilliantly in a little more than seven minutes.

I am submitting to you the link. This is to an article talking about the Jon Stewart show. I cannot show a clip from Comedy Central and expect it to be up on my site for more than thirty seconds. You have to scroll down to the Stewart video in You Tube format.

This is the link.

Have fun and see how pointed humor can be.

James Pilant

Banks Foreclosures In August The Highest Monthly Total EVER!

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, Government Failure, Philosophy of Business, White Collar Crime2 Comments

From an article by William Alden –

August saw more Americans lose their homes to foreclosure than any other month on record, RealtyTrac reported today. Banks repossessed a total of 95,364 properties in August, a 25 percent increase from the same period in 2009 and a 2 percent increase over this May’s previous record. Foreclosure filings of all types, including default notices, scheduled auctions and bank repossessions (the three major stages of the foreclosure process), increased to 338,836 in the month, a 4 percent jump from July.

Can there be any better evidence of robo – signing (the practice of mortgage companies simply have attorneys sign off on mortgages as if they had examined the paperwork for accuracy and legality [like whether or not the bank actually owned the property]) than these enormous numbers of foreclosures?

Foreclosing on people’s homes without doing the most minimal required legal work is “highly unethical.” (I don’t really want to use that phrase, but children might be reading my blog.)

Robo signing is profitable. You can see from the numbers just how streamlined the process can be if you avoid following the law.

But isn’t that the current philosophy in the “real” world? Isn’t the money the only thing that matters? And who are these homeowners anyway, just a bunch of dead beats. Why should they have any rights? They signed the note, didn’t they?

Yeah, do you know what note they signed? The actual amount of what they owed? Whether or not the home was actually the property of the foreclosing bank? Whether or not they were even in default?

I guess I’m just a strange person. I think you shouldn’t take people’s home casually. I think it is a very serious matter. Perhaps I don’t live in the real world. Maybe I’m one of those utopian thinkers who have expectations all out of accord with reality.

Or maybe, just maybe, justice is still important in this nation.

James Pilant

Ohio Attorney General Sues GMAC Mortgage Division – Texas Attorney General Halts Foreclosures!

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, Corporate Social Responsibility, ethics, Government Failure, Philosophy of Business, White Collar Crime1 Comment

It has begun, there will be lawsuits filed across the country to punish the foreclosure industry for their violations of state laws. Can they stop these crimes? What is the Attorney General in our state going to do?

The Ohio Attorney General is filing suit and the Massachusetts Attorney General is considering doing the same.

From Huffington Post –

Attorney General Richard Cordray said Wednesday the alleged fraud could involve hundreds of foreclosures in the state. The lawsuit claims the company’s employees signed and filed false affidavits to mislead courts. Cordray called the alleged fraud the “tip of an iceberg of industrywide abuse of the foreclosure process.

The Texas Attorney General’s Office is halting foreclosures across the state – From CBS7 – West Texas –

The Texas Attorney General has called for a halt on all home foreclosures, this includes all sales of property that were previously foreclosed upon and all evictions of people living in previously foreclosed properties.

State Attorney General, Greg Abbott, has sent a letter to thirty loan service companies freezing foreclosures in the state as they begin an investigation into foreclosure practices in the state.

“Evicting someone out of their home is very serious, and it needs to be done in the proper manner,” said Western National Bank Financial Advisor Mickey Cargile.

Will there be any justice?

Stay with my blog, I’m not letting this subject go until we get to the end of it.

James Pilant

Homeowners Betrayed

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, Corporate Social Responsibility, Economic measurement, ethics, Government Failure, Philosophy of Business, White Collar Crime2 Comments

I have been accused of being shrill. Today is the day, I should tear the wallpaper off the walls in hot raging anger. The Senate passed a bill on the last day of the session by unanimous consent that essentially solves the banks’ mortgage foreclosure problems.

Have a read – (from Reuters)

The bill, passed without public debate in a way that even surprised its main sponsor, Republican Representative Robert Aderholt, requires courts to accept as valid document notarizations made out of state, making it harder to challenge the authenticity of foreclosure and other legal documents.

The timing raised eyebrows, coming during a rising furor over improper affidavits and other filings in foreclosure actions by large mortgage processors such as GMAC, JPMorgan and Bank of America.

Questions about improper notarizations have figured prominently in challenges to the validity of these court documents, and led to widespread halts of foreclosure proceedings.

The legislation could protect bank and mortgage processors from liability for false or improperly prepared documents.

Do we live in a nation where citizens matter? Hundreds of thousands of mortgages have been done without actual knowledge of the facts. This is not legal. But here comes Congress just when the crisis is beginning to develop. And Congress like the cavalry rides not to rescue the homeowners but to make it difficult or impossible for them to challenge inaccurate or false documents. It will also make it difficult or impossible to sue for redress by these simple Americans who lived their lives believing falsely they had a government that was concerned in some way about their rights.

It’s not law yet. It awaits that “stalwart defender” of the public, Barack Obama, to sign or veto. What do you bet?

This is incredible. The mortgage companies are caught committing essentially fraud on a massive scale at the very least lying to the court system not once but hundreds of thousands of times(probably several million times) and the government acts to legalize their acts just as the scandal is revealed.

I don’t know what to say. I am well aware that besides this frail web site, I have no influence. I want to go outside and scream. Doesn’t someone, anyone care about the homeowners who have been abused hundreds of thousands of times?

What do these huge accumulations of money have to do to get in trouble? Apparently there is nothing they can’t do. Apparently there is no line they can cross, that will cause our government to act against them.

Will there be any action taken? Will there be any outrage? Will there be any investigations and will they lead to any actual action?

Stay tuned. I’m not finished with this yet.

James Pilant

Let’s Have A Moratorium On Foreclosures!

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, Corporate Social Responsibility, Economic measurement, ethics, Government Failure, Philosophy of Business

That’s right. Until we have evidence that the banks intend to follow established procedure when foreclosing homes instead of the hopeful, magic of the “our people don’t make errors” world.

No one has the right to take people’s home based on supposition or simply trusting companies who have proven by their behavior that they have no interest in justice and fair dealing.

Let’s stop it and use the time to do an across the board re examination of those mortgages foreclosed without proper procedure. It is obvious that homes have been taken and money charged without legal justification.

That’s not how we do things in the United States of America!

We are a nation of honor, where fair dealing and good faith are enshrined in the law. That’s right, they are on the books. They are part of the common law tradition in this country. They are still used to decide cases. This is one where they apply.

I’m not the only one who thinks a moratorium is a good idea. – (from Reuters)

An influential U.S. senator on Tuesday raised the prospect of an industry-wide moratorium on foreclosures as he pressed three banks accused of improperly kicking borrowers out of their homes to outline steps they are taking to fix their procedures.

“It is simply inexcusable that proper oversight proceedings were not in place, especially when dealing with matters as monumental as the seizure of a family’s home,” Senator Robert Menendez wrote to the heads of JPMorgan Chase and Co, Bank of America Corp and Ally Financial Inc, formerly known as GMAC and 56.3 percent-owned by taxpayers.

“At least one credit rating agency, Fitch, states that it believes this problem is widespread among banks and servicers, which raises the question of whether other banks should impose a moratorium until this lack of oversight is corrected,” wrote Menendez, the head of a Senate subcommittee on housing.

It’s a good idea. It’s something that should be done in the name of simple justice.

Simple justice may not be the fashion in dealing with the “self correcting” mechanism of the free market. But it’s still something I believe in.

James Pilant

Robo-Signers – Not R2D2!

On By southwerkIn business ethics, Capitalism, ethics, Government Failure, Philosophy of Business4 Comments

In an article featured in ProPublica by Marian Wang, the phenomenon of signing foreclosure document without knowledge of the contents is discussed –

Last week, we noted that the discovery of “robo-signers” — employees who signed off on thousands of foreclosure documents without much, if any, knowledge of their accuracy — had caused Ally Financial’s GMAC mortgage unit to freeze foreclosures in 23 states where foreclosures require a court order.

You’d think that all banks using the practice would be humiliated and chastened by a practice that misinforms the court as to their actual knowledge of the mortgage documents. You would be wrong, big time wrong.

From further down in the article –

The Associated Press reported late Sunday that a Wells Fargo executive acknowledged in a May deposition that he had signed hundreds of foreclosure documents each week without verifying any information aside from the date. The company, nonetheless, told AP it had no plans to halt foreclosures and was confident of the documents’ accuracy. (As we’ve noted, other banks — including those that have chosen to halt foreclosures — have also expressed confidence in the accuracy of their documents and played down the likelihood of mistaken foreclosures, despite the flawed paperwork.)

See, Wells Fargo, knows its documents are correct without even looking at them. Now, that’s a crack staff! Errors are discovered in mortgage filings all the time but they don’t have any.

The site, Complaints Board, catalogs Wells Fargo mortgage complaints. ConsumerAffairs.com also lists Wells Fargo complaints. But don’t worry, they only verified the dates but all the rest needs no examination!

This is a pretty high level of arrogance particularly when the court is being presented unverified documents. They taught us in law school to be scared of judges. Wells Fargo is apparently unaware of this basic rule. Telling judges you have verified data you have not could get them in the fining and contempt citation mood not even mentioning that throwing the case out of court thing.

Let’s see what happens next. I’m betting they can’t keep the practice of robo-signing up.

James Pilant